My brow is furrowed again and I should get this out before my wife gets home to hear yet, another one of my Andy Rooney-ish tirades on ‘how my day was’
So help me out here. How is this application helpful? In being social in any environment we are more or less on the same page. Most people feel insecure about something if not many things. It takes effort to expand beyond your own self-consciousness sometimes to get a thought out past your own nose. So why, when we are shielded with the plastic from our computers, and most likely miles between us, would you feel the need to be more excepted for what you express?
Taking a look at the ‘what’s it for‘ page, let’s run it down:
- “How many hours have you wasted trying to think of something suitably witty, funny and original for your status on Facebook or Twitter?”
Not nearly as many I’m sure as days that are wasted mindlessly sitting in front of the TV. Thinking is genuinely regarded as a natural and healthy thing to do and not something to be discouraged. That is, unless you are watching TV 😉
- “Let’s face it, a status like “Dave is mowing the lawn” or “Kate is asleep” is not going to impress that huge entourage of friends you’ve amassed.”
Gee, you mean now that I have amassed my very own entourage I should just spend my time with cut-n-paste churned updates from the bot. I got one even better. Why not just hire myself a social media assistant to churn babble for me. I’ve got better things to do like take Italian lessons using Rosetta Stone to build an entourage of Real Estate/Vespa enthusiasts in on Meemi.com. My take is that it’s opt in on social networks anyway. I understand everyone’s complaints about the banality of updates like Sbux is out of half and half or I’m walking my dog, but what if it does mean something in the context of how you are relating to others in the moment. I love to hear my family and friends are up through href=”http://www.facebook.com/home.php?”>Facebook et al. It helps fill in the blanks and creates even more meaningful conversations when we have time to be present with one another. I’m sure all of us by now have benefited from the use of Social Platforms, at least over the past year or so, we know our President Elect has. What if all of a sudden your friends and family started speaking bot, giving you updates on a Thursday afternoon like “Johnny is boycotting shampoo and demanding real poo!” I would either stop paying attention altogether or put plan an diaper intervention.
- “Never fear! Your days of boring status updates are over! Simply type your name, indicate whether you are a boy or a girl, then hit Generate.”
What, so gender specific? Obviously not for those with ‘San Francisco Values‘ 😀
- “You will be served up a brand new, sparkly status all ready to be copied and pasted into Facebook, Twitter or whichever social networking site you like best.”
The bots can’t have everything. You give them your time, your attention, and money. Hand them over your free will to think, create, and share the uniqueness of who you are, then what’s next? Yeah, I know, it’s not a big deal when you’re objective is to be liked. So whatever is clever for you and yours.. reblip, reblog, and generatus into the next half-life. Better yet, twitterfeed you reblogs, reblip your amazon suggestions, jott your tweetlaters to later set for automatic updates and canned message ‘welcomes’. Oh wait, your microblog is now blinged and your Facebook page is generating ‘generatus’ too. Don’t forget to Magpie your twitter, so your profile is now just a flash banner ad away from being a genuine splog. For the sake of having a more buckshot Social Media strategy I would further suggest you Ping.fm all of these updates in order to have a consistent multi-platform outreach, you never know who’s out their ‘listening’ or feeding on your friendship. If your friendz don’t love you, the google bots will. I’m sure a specific niche use keyword packer for generated status updates is in the works. You might just want to name your first born ‘Meta tag’ Goo goo ga ga – what will baby Meta’s first words be?
I don’t care what you do with social media really, let’s just not forget that it is the technology that allows us to be more social, not the other way around. Just because we can do more tricks doesn’t mean we have to. Now I’m starting to sound like a real curmudgeon.. oops!.. feeling a bit self-conscious. Let’s defer to the generator’s tag cloud and.. yes, manufactured response says: “Brad is more than ever before” Status update complete.
As everyone seems now to be experiencing, these platforms, especially through blogging are a great place to engage and learn and grow together, but nothing is as game as what happens when the LCD lids shut and we get offline. It’s the way it will always be, no matter how dependent on the machines we become.
Real generousity come from sharing the gift of what you have to offer. Now I’ve shared mine.
Jeff Brown says:
Amen — and thanks.
November 20, 2008 — 10:17 pm
Steven Leung says:
Good rant and moral, but I think the folks who built that application meant it ironically.
Which is a good sign that there’s going to be a shift in the Internet’s next phase of development.
November 21, 2008 — 12:19 am
Missy Caulk says:
I can’t see real people doing this, but some large news magazines or TV shows may use it, just like they throw their tweets in for updates.
Not real…..
November 21, 2008 — 4:33 am
Eric Blackwell says:
I would agree with Steven…
but like ALL other forms of communication…
there is NO substitute for authenticity.
Eric
November 21, 2008 — 4:54 am
Heather Elias says:
I love me a good Brad rant. Definitely spot-on. Letting bots generate your status reports = virtual life hacking… If I don’t have time to be genuine online, LCD is staying shut..
November 21, 2008 — 5:41 am
Steven Leung says:
Eric – You’re right about authenticity, wish I’d used that word! I had a realization so there’s one thing I want to add to that argument.
Some folks use a lot of subtext. Unfortunately, when your communication style is completely straightforward in a world that’s nuanced, you can be authentic but misinterpreted: people parse words through their own needs and experiences and there are some areas where you see it all the time.
Some folks may genuinely think that Generatus status updates are funny or clever. Who am I to judge whether they’re genuine or not?
Personally, I’d never limit anyone else’s word choice with regards to expressing ideas (or even social media status — anyone remember .plan files?) but I’ve always agreed with folks like Missy and Heather about things like Generatus. Be real, be genuine, online and offline.
November 21, 2008 — 6:24 am
Cristofer Gross says:
Thanks, Brad, for donning the curmudgeon shield of honor. Commenters here seem to be in agreement with you. As an observer for a couple generations now, I think we need to watch the encroachment of PR and marketing mentality (particularly hard for folks like me who make my living doing it). Facebook I use, and I enjoy hearing someone is “staying in bed all day with the blues” much more than one-liners like the “sham-poo” joke (though I love puns, in their place . . . like Colbert). Some folks will probably want a product like this, and others won’t. Let’s hope we have the cleverness to know the difference. Keep on ranting!
November 21, 2008 — 7:15 am
J Boyer Morristown NJ Condos says:
I still have not found the time for most of these social networking sites. They seem to chew up so much of your time and so perhaps during the christmas lul I will work on a few profiles.
November 21, 2008 — 9:31 am
Brad Coy says:
>I think the folks who built that application meant it ironically
If pop art is what it is, then wrap a few up for me in Xpapr for the holidays – though it might not be as fun as a Magic 8-ball. Although, if it was designed for entertainments sake then I guess a generated Monty Python update like “Brad thinks that strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government” is pretty damn funny, I just would not put it out there as ‘my thought’. 🙂
November 21, 2008 — 1:12 pm
Brad Coy says:
>NO substitute for authenticity
Cheers! The idea of this app was just a catalyst for something I had been feeling with the nature of communication and the many wonder applications that I have been coming across. It’s fascinating when with what we find in ‘easier to use’ technology and muck it up with more complicated branches and user plans to streamline something that’s been made simple by automating things that don’t need automation and coming up with silly social strategies.
November 21, 2008 — 1:18 pm
Brad Coy says:
>I can’t see real people doing this
>Let’s hope we have the cleverness to know the difference
Hmmm…
November 21, 2008 — 1:23 pm
Brad Coy says:
>They seem to chew up so much of your time
This is very true. Keeping it simple is the best advice I can offer along with researching some of the great posts archived right here at Bloodhound. It’s best to look at your profiles as a work in progress and just get something started when you have a chance. I will build in the basics and put down on my calender a couple of dates in the future to go back and flesh them out. Ubiquity is a bit overrated as well, look to google to find what best suits your needs as far as having profiles on social sites. There are the standard popular sites of course, but I would agree with some others I know in that some of the real sugar is to be found going local.
November 21, 2008 — 1:36 pm
Vicki Moore says:
What about the new buzz word transparency? Where is it in this app? I agree we all have insecurities we either like each other or we don’t. I don’t want to be friends with someone who’s pretending. That one’s just weird.
November 21, 2008 — 10:38 pm