I live in an amazing world, which is to say a world by which I am continuously amazed, without boundary or graduation.
Here’s an example: I cannot for the life of me understand why National Association of Realtors President Pat Combs has not called me personally to ask me to come to Las Vegas for the convention to tell the NAR what it’s getting wrong.
Now you may think that’s an amazing hubris on my part, but in fact I am the obvious candidate for the job. Redfin.com’s Glenn Kelman is the only plausible alternative, but he is too much at odds with traditional real estate to qualify. I, on the other hand, am — on paper at least — the pot-bellied poster-child of the NAR — GRI, ABR, CRS the hard way. Add to that that I have spent many hundreds of hours detailing what’s wrong with the NAR, and have built a national platform from with to promulgate those arguments and, from my point of view — from Planet Cluetrain — the invitation should have been forthcoming months ago.
But there my amazement does not end. For, upon receipt of such an invitation, I would have to decide what to do about it. It wouldn’t be an easy choice. I think I might love to do it — on my birthday, no less — particularly if the audience were very hostile. But I don’t see that there could be any enduring benefit to it. If Pat Combs had ever even heard of the Cluetrain, she wouldn’t have any need to hear from me.
A nicer way, and I could do this easily enough, would be to go in and talk about the exciting world of Web 2.0 — and it seems likely to me that someone will be doing just that at some breakout session or another. And this will be just as stupid and pointless as the Inman BloggerDoggles, where earnest, well-intentioned people try to talk about community while a horde of congenital note-takers scribbles down tips on how to fake sincerity to snag more leads.
“The world sorts itself out” is what I said to a BloodhoundBlog contributor as an antidote to a topical indignation. I don’t need to be invited to the NAR. The NAR will come to me, one mind at a time, and we will each of us go to learn from Jim Duncan, when the moment is right, or Dan Melson or Daniel Rothamel or Jay Thompson. There’s room on the Cluetrain for everyone — and there is no way to bar anyone from catching a ride — or catching a clue.
This is my answer to everything: Disintermediate the bums! I don’t want to talk to the NAR, what I want is to live in a time where the NAR no longer matters in any way at all. This is an attainable objective, and this — what I am doing right now — this is how it will be attained. This is why they should have invited me long ago, and, amazingly enough, this is precisely why they have not. Vesuvius growls and grumbles and still they think what we are doing is graffiti.
“When all you have is a hammer,” we are taught, “everything looks like a nail.” That reads as a promise of prowess, and it only seems misplaced in the short-run. Over the long haul, treating every problem as the same one problem can have salutary consequences, with these nets we traverse as the best proof yet.
But the sentence also reads to me as a confession of weakness, and my instant reaction is to say, “When all you have is a hammer, use it to pound out a bigger hammer.”
This is where BloodhoundBlog is headed. You can see it in our numbers if you pay attention, but the numbers don’t even matter. We are sui generis, a thing apart, a universe unto our own. We stand on the shoulders of giants, as does everyone, but we stand tall on the shoulders of giants. We hammer harder, longer, louder — and, invited or not, we will be heard.
Technorati Tags: blogging, disintermediation, real estate, real estate marketing
Kevin Sharkey says:
Well done Greg! After 18 years of banging my head against the wall on the general topic of getting rid of NAR and its underlings, it is exciting to see the numbers of like-minded souls swelling in numbers.
The following is from Paul Kantner in one of the best albums made for its time: Blows Against The Empire. The whole album reminds me of the current relationship between the Bloodhounds of the world and the “Powers That Be.”
Wherever I go I see you people
I see you people just like me
And whatever you do I want to do
And the Pooh and you and me together make three
Let’s go together
Let’s go together
Let’s go together
Wave goodbye to Amerika
Say hello to the garden
You know I see – I see the way you feel
And I know that your life is real
Pioneer searcher refugee
I follow you and you follow me
Let’s go together…oo
Wave goodbye…
Say hello
October 24, 2007 — 9:01 am
Daniel Rothamel says:
Greg,
Thanks for the mention. I am humbled. I also completely understand your point of view and very much admire what you do here at BHB.
I, for one, am attending the NAR convention for one simple reason– to be seen more than heard. The Internet has made it easy to lob grenades from a great distance. The consequence has been that many (the NAR brass included, no doubt) can easily dismiss people because they don’t have to see them. They know “of” people without really “knowing” people. I know that most people are very sensitive to criticism, and that they tend to do better with words from friends rather than strangers. That is also why I am trying to plan some sort of blogger get-together during the conference. If I can get one meaningful relationship out of the endeavor, it will be worth it.
I can stand outside the castle and shout all I want, but they don’t have to invite me in. I think it may be time to try to scale the walls.
I also think that the industry will be better if we can eliminate the NAR as it currently functions. That doesn’t necessarily mean we need to do away with it completely. People are social animals who want to belong. The elimination of NAR would merely create space to be filled with something else. The other issue is that NAR is a professional organization. I don’t think that the public really cares one way or the other. The fate of the NAR is in the hands of its members– that’s me and you. Doing our best to affect change, however we can, is the best we can do. You are most certainly doing it on BHB, others are going to do it in their own way. As you have said, what we are doing is not the future of real estate– it is real estate RIGHT NOW.
Keep it up, and I’ll let you know how it goes if I make it over the wall. . .
October 24, 2007 — 12:57 pm
Jay Thompson says:
“Keep it up, and I’ll let you know how it goes if I make it over the wall. . .”
I’ll give you a boost Daniel. Look forward to meeting you in Vegas.
October 24, 2007 — 3:50 pm
Benn says:
I believe we’ll be in vegas too. See you there.
October 24, 2007 — 6:44 pm