In today’s real estate market, the refrain from Realtors is the same: “These sellers are living in La La Land (or Neverland). Everyone is thinking their home is worth much more than it is. We can’t get them to see the truth!” Alas, the “truth” is that this is an age-old problem that is not necessarily intrinsic to any particular market, but may be a little worse than normal in 2006-07. The history books are replete with examples dating as far back as the paleolithic period of neanderthal men and women chasing Realtors from their caves with raised clubs over a price dispute. This euphoric optimism of the common home seller has been studied by the American Medical Dissociation, and it has coined a neologism: Schitzo Prospectus Actualis Capitalis. (Editor’s Note: a break with reality concerning the expectation of material gain.)
The acronym, SPAC (pronounced “Space”), has entered modern parlance to speak of sellers with the disease. “Spacers,” as these unfortunates have become known, appear to be causing Realtors apoplectic frustration. But what is this disease, and how has it reached epic proportions?
One of the contributing factors of the disease appears to be neighborhood gossip. It is not uncommon for homeowners in a given community to keep each other apprised of the going rate for homes through the neighborhood grapevine. Our reporter asked a local homeowner to give her opinion of her home’s value:
WUSA Reporter: “What do you think your home is worth today, Mrs. Bon-Mot?
Mrs. Bon-Mot: “Well, the Pastiche’s place down on Maple Drive is very similar to ours, and his sold about a month ago for $525,000. It took him a couple of months to sell, the market being what it is, but it did sell. Now, our home has Teflon wallpaper, which his didn’t. Also, we have an above-ground pool that the kids just love. Oh, we also got a new air conditioner about, oh. . .ten years ago? Yeah. All these things add up! So, I would expect that we could get about $550,000, maybe $560,000.
Our intrepid reporter, after researching county records and the local MLS data, found the truth about the Pastiche’s sale:
1. The Pastiche’s home was 1357 square feet bigger that the Bon-Mot’s.
2. The Pastiche’s home was on the market with 4 different Realtors for a total of 296 days.
3. The Pastiche’s home was originally listed for $495,000, and eventually sold for $421,000.
4. According to MLS data, the Pastiche’s home had been extensively remodeled in 2002 including new floors, paint, pebble-tech play pool, and a new kitchen.
So, how does this information get passed along and corrupted? According to local specialist Johnson Smack of Swindle & Crouch Realty, homeowners hear what they want to hear: “It’s an ongoing problem. So and so tells so and so, and the story gets twisted until the guy down the street who sold a year ago had a dilapidated hut that sold for way more than it should have. We see it all the time. These ‘Spacers’ really need to get with reality.” How does Mr. Smack deal with these idiosyncrasies?
“I just show them the comps,” says Smack, “and let them see the truth. That guy down the road from you had a nicer house, and it didn’t sell for as much as you think it did.”
However, this revelation can sometimes lead to volatility, as our erstwhile reporter discovered. When revealing our own research concerning the sale of the Pastiche’s property to Mrs. Bon-Mot, she at first demurred. “No, that’s not right. Maybe you’ve got the wrong home. The Pastiche’s didn’t have all that stuff,” she said. When confronted with pictures of Mr. & Mrs. Pastiche holding a sold sign in their front yard that our reporters found posted on their former Realtor’s Website, Mrs. Bon-Mot became indignant and semi-politely asked our reporter to leave.
SPAC disease is challenging medical researchers across the US to find a cure that will enable the sluggish economy to regain its footing in the coming years. The housing sector is a major driver of the aggregate economy, and while home seller’s suffer from SPAC, things look grim. Biological chemists, psychologists, and even holistic specialists have been facing the challenge head on. “We have begun looking at different forms of hallucinogenic drugs to combat the problem,” says Dr. Mustapha Obslooke, a spokesman for I.G. Farben, “The initial trials have been giving our people an optomistic outlook. We expect that, after FDA testing this fall, we will be able to get help where it is needed most.”
According to department staff at the University of Tulsa’s Jung Research Center, electo-shock therapy and traditional prefrontal lobotomy do not seem to be the answer. One student researcher, on condition of anonymity, reported that “sellers just do not respond to this approach. After we get them cleaned up and wipe the saliva from their faces, their responses to our inquiries is just not adequate to suggest a significant change.” Researchers are now involved in removing parts of the hypocampus of sellers in an effort to combat the disease. The first trials of this new procedure have proven inconclusive, but there are reports of unexpected side benefits, notably an ease of irritable bowel syndrome.
Holistic specialists have had limited results in their treatments. According to Radiant Moonbeam, an independent practitioner of holistic medicine, her patients are having some success. “We really had hoped for better results, “she says, “but, until now, our healing herbs, along with a regiment of progressive muscle relaxation and sunshine colon-cleanse (patent pending) have only gotten a few thousand dollars relief.”
Specialists are still working on the problem, and may have new reports out this summer. Until then, the disease will have to run its course. There is some hope among researchers that the body’s own immune system will begin to fight back, giving new hope to the US homeowner, economist, and Realtor. We’ll keep you posted.
reprinted by permission of The Daily Bender
Brian Brady says:
Uh oh, a couple of poets, and a satirist now. The bar keeps getting raised.
Allen, this was comically true.
February 14, 2007 — 10:09 pm
Russell Shaw says:
LOL. Fantastic post, sir.
February 15, 2007 — 12:24 am
Allen Butler says:
I figured you might like that. You being a fan of L. R. Hubbard and all. I attribute my satirical tendencies to his Mission Earth series. Oh, what a day. . .
February 15, 2007 — 12:29 am
Kris Berg says:
Fabulous! Great job, Allen, and oh-so true.
February 15, 2007 — 8:08 am
Dave Barnes says:
I enjoyed it very much.
But, my house is worth more than my low-life neighbors’.
February 15, 2007 — 8:59 am
Todd Tarson says:
Well done, and extremely timely for me since I just got ‘fired’ by a ‘spacer’ yesterday. I shouldn’t have taken the listing in the first place, but some how some way, the new broker they hired is putting a higher listing price on the home that is already about $100,000 over priced.
February 15, 2007 — 9:45 am
Kevin Boer says:
Here in the Bay Area, we have not only Spacer Selleritis but also another species that had been dormant for a few months, Spacer Buyeritis. Symptoms include extrapolating from a story they read about declining prices in, say, Kansas City, to believing that a home listed here for a $1M will only sell for $850K. They’ve also been known to argue with a set of comps thusly: “There’s no way that home sold for $1.2M!”
February 15, 2007 — 10:49 am
Jim Cosgrove says:
Thanks for a great laugh! I talked with a prospective Seller the other day who told me he wanted to list $200,000 (25%) above my CMA. He said he agreed with my comps but wanted to “leave some wiggle room”.
February 15, 2007 — 11:55 am
Jonathan Greene says:
Genius.
February 15, 2007 — 11:58 am
Chris says:
Excellent post! On brokers tour last Firday we had a good laugh at one of the listings presented. Asking $425k, $100k-$125k over priced. The listing agent was like bring your buyers by! Yeah sure, I’ll get right on it…
February 15, 2007 — 4:15 pm
Sandy says:
I am late to the party here, but this is a great post!
June 27, 2007 — 8:35 am
Paula Bean says:
I HAVE the cure for SPAC sellers!!
Invented several years ago by yours truly, when at a listing appt with a s/s (SPAC SELLER) and a NIT (newbie in training).
Feel free to steal this if you wish, or if you try it and it works, donations are accepted and appreciated
The seller had done his homework, went to the county tax records, added 300% to the tax assessed market value, and since house was the Taj Mahol, he crunched some numbers and decided it was worth $650,000. My comps, which showed $450K must be incorrect, since data can be manipulated, and several of the houses he knew for a fact sold for more money in less time than the MLS stated.
After a few minutes of sitting by his pool with my NIT, I rose forward in my chair, leaned over the table and told the seller I completely agreed with him. His house WAS much better than any others in his neighborhood, and yes, data can be spindled, folded and mutilated and I was absolutely sure his county assessment was probably too low as well. I then proceeded to tell him we should list at $850k (grin, keep reading, it is long, but worth it!)
The NIT is sitting beside me with a “Deer in the headlights” look on her face. I know she had to be thinking “THIS woman is going to teach me how to get a listing? WTF?!)
The seller now moves forward in his chair, his eyes wide and glowing with delight that She’d finally found the perfect REALTOR®! He asks me if I think we can get $850 because then he could buy a better house when he moved.
Happy – Happy! Joy-Joy!
I said “yes, in 30 years, it’s just a matter of how long you want to list the property with me. I just spent 30 minutes explaining the comps, informing you of how appraisers work and why you won’t get $650K, but my job is to sell your house and if I have a listing for 30 years, I’m most sure that by then we can get $850 for your house, probably even more, however, I’m now sure if either of us will be alive in 30 years, so that may be an issue, but hey, our kids can get the money….now just sign right here and I’ll get right to work for you.
I thought he would fall out of his chair! The NIT was trying diligently not to laugh, but the seller started laughing his butt off, tears pouring down his face. Once he recovered he said I was funny. I told him so was his perception of the value of his house (of course all this took place with a smile on my face). He declined my 30 year listing agreement; I declined to list his house.
I then told him he would find someone who would do it, because they’d want the buyer calls on it – or he could do fsbo and save even more money since we are grossly overpaid. I stood up, shook his hand and wished him luck.
He took my advice, listed it with another agent for $675K, 6 months later reduced the price to $650K, 6 months after that he listed with another company and lowered it to $625K, then went fsbo for a year, then he called me back to sell his house.
And (drum roll please) 2 months later I sold it to my own buyer
The moral of this story I told my NIT after we got in the car, is that there really aren’t any overpriced listings, there are only listings with time frames that aren’t long enough.
WARNING:
Not all S/S’s will react the same way, so you must be able to run like lightening prior to using this method, and good insurance wouldn’t hurt either,lol, but it works 80% of the time for me. I’m an adventurous person though, and once I know I am not going to take a listing, I start trying things just to see if I can get away with it, and in the long run, it makes for a good laugh around the water cooler at the office and it is good to use whilst training agents, it teaches them to be brave, bold and persistent.
June 18, 2008 — 10:23 pm